Saving Tips With Diesel Cars and Trucks

CARPHOTO-2733

Diesel vehicles get remarkable fuel economy, but it’s sometimes not enough to make them a better value overall than their gas counterparts.

The main reason is the higher pricetag: on average a diesel is $5,045 more than a gas-powered version of the same model, according to Vincentric LLC, a research firm in Bingham Farms, Mich.

Beyond the purchase amount, diesels also end up costing a little bit more to own and maintain. Which gets injected into the exhaust and neutralizes some of the pollutants, that’s partly because some new diesel vehicles are required to have a reservoir of urea.

With this so-called “clean-diesel” technology, emissions are actually cleaner than what comes from many gasoline vehicles-and that is a major role reversal. But there is added maintenance involved in replenishing the reservoirs and ensuring the more complex diesel engine is running properly.

“We found that diesels typically have slightly higher insurance, repair and maintenance costs,” says David Wurster, president of Vincentric, which specializes in calculating total cost of ownership and chose diesels for its latest alternative fuel analysis.

“An additional noteworthy point is that on a percentage basis, diesels have lower depreciation, but because they cost more to purchase, their total dollars of depreciation are higher,” Wurster says. (Some might argue that diesel is not technically an alternative fuel, but it’s not quite mainstream in the United States either, provided that only a small fraction of vehicles use it.)

Diesel vs. gas

In a detailed analysis comparing diesel and gas versions of the same models, Vincentric calculated the price of ownership over five years, assuming 15,000 miles of driving annually. The company discovered that, in many cases, particularly with trucks and vans, the gas-powered model would wind up costing owners less in the end, despite using more fuel.

But you will find enough exceptions to keep anyone who wants to purchase a diesel happy.

Vincentric included 23 diesel vehicles within its alternative fuel analysis-which is pretty much every consumer and commercial diesel currently discounted in the United States. Once all the expenses are tallied, the analysis shows, nine diesels are cost-effective. Eight of those are consumer models.

In Pictures: Diesel Cars And Trucks That Could Save You Money

Mercedes-Benz has the most vehicles on the list. The company has five of the eight slots, including the top two.

The diesel that delivers the most significant savings over its gas equivalent is a pricey luxury crossover- the 2012 Mercedes GL350 Bluetec 4Matic. (The “Bluetec” label is Mercedes-speak for diesel, and “4Matic” is its all-wheel drive system.)

Owners will spend $10,128 less over five-years on the GL350 than a gas-powered GL450 4Matic, by Vincentric’s calculations. Nearly half of the savings-$4,750-is the consequence of the GL350 using less fuel, and therefore costing less overall in the pump during those 5 years.

In accordance with the U.S, though filling up with diesel is more expensive-in recent weeks, about 25 cents more per gallon than regular gas. Energy Information Administration-diesel vehicles much like the GL350 acquire more mileage for that buck.

The GL350’s 19 miles per gallon overall is 27 percent a lot better than the 15 miles per gallon overall that the GL450 gets using gas. So, on a percentage basis, diesels have lower depreciation, but because they will cost more to purchase, their total dollars of depreciation are higher,” Wurster says,. That’s the fuel costs for the diesel workout to less per mile.“An additional noteworthy point. It’s not exactly mainstream in the United States either, given that merely a small fraction of vehicles use it., although (Some might argue that diesel is not technically an alternative fuel)

Diesel vs. gas

In a detailed analysis comparing gas and diesel versions of the same models, Vincentric calculated the cost of ownership over five-years, assuming 15,000 miles of driving annually. The organization found that, most of the time, particularly with vans and trucks, the gas-powered model would end up costing owners less in the long run, despite using more fuel.

But there are enough exceptions to hold anyone who wishes to buy a diesel happy.

Vincentric included 23 diesel vehicles in its alternative fuel analysis-which can be just about every consumer and commercial diesel currently on sale in america. Once each of the expenses are tallied, the analysis shows, nine diesels are cost-effective. Eight of people are consumer models.

In Pictures: Diesel Cars And Trucks That Will Save You Money

Mercedes-Benz provides the most vehicles on the list. The organization has five of the eight slots, like the top two.

The diesel that delivers the most important savings over its gas equivalent can be a pricey luxury crossover- the 2012 Mercedes GL350 Bluetec 4Matic. (The “Bluetec” label is Mercedes-speak for diesel, and “4Matic” is its all-wheel drive system.)

Owners will spend $10,128 less over five years about the GL350 compared to a gas-powered GL450 4Matic, by Vincentric’s calculations. Nearly 50 % of the savings-$4,750-is the result of the GL350 using less fuel, and thus costing less overall at the pump during those five years.

According to the U.S, though filling up with diesel is a lot more expensive-in recent weeks, about 25 cents more per gallon than regular gas. Energy Information Administration-diesel vehicles like the GL350 get more mileage for the buck.

The GL350’s 19 miles per gallon overall is 27 percent better than the 15 mpg overall that this GL450 gets using gas. So, the fuel costs for the diesel work out to less per mile.

Ranking second in the Vincentric list of cost-effective diesels is a Mercedes luxury sedan. The 2012 Mercedes S350 Bluetec 4Matic will save owners $6,015 compared to a S550, which has a twin-turbo V8 that runs on gasoline, Vincentric says. The savings is mostly on fuel-$4,003.

The S550 is simply available with rear-wheel drive, whereas the diesel S350 is simply offered with all of-wheel drive. This may cause the S350’s better fuel economy more remarkable, as driving two wheels as an alternative to four is inherently more potent. The S350 gets a complete 25 miles per gallon on diesel, an improvement of around 32 percent from the S550’s overall 19 miles per gallon of gas.

Also earning a spot in the rankings are the diesel versions from the Audi A3, the BMW X5, the Ford F-350, and the Volkswagen Touareg. Another Mercedes diesels on the list would be the E-Class, the M-Class along with the R-Class. According to the level of savings., (Click here to go to the slideshow to see the full set of diesels that will save you money, ranked)

Ford Tough

The sole commercial vehicle to make the cut will be the Ford F-350. The heavy-duty, full-size pickup truck can be a popular selection for contractors among others who need its hauling and towing brawn.

Of the trucks in Ford’s F-Series, the F-350 will be the second most effective, and its capability makes it costly. Going through the manufacturer’s suggested retail price, the F-350 starts at $30,165, and the diesel engine is really a $7,960 option.

But with any vehicle, the retail price is generally just a guideline for negotiations. So Vincentric also factors other data into its equation, like dealer invoice pricing and consumer rebates. Its intent is to find out what buyers are in reality paying.